Author: paula.mcgrew@gmail.com

It is always amazing to me how things that have no apparent connection can, in fact, be interconnected in a powerful way. For example, consider the following:

• • • • • Commencement 2018 at WVWC
        • Assembly at Wesleyan on March 6, 1947 (required attendance)
        • A Philosophy professor (1994-2019),  Rob Hull
        • An English Literature professor (1919-1955), Lewis H. Chrisman
        • The Great Depression
        • Hymns
        • Sermons
        • Book Reviews
        • Current Events
        • Probably many others I haven’t even thought of, but you get the point.

Having retired in July of 2017, I wasn’t necessarily expected to attend Commencement the following year, but many of my former students were graduating and I wouldn’t have missed it for anything. As luck would have it, I ended up sitting next to Professor Rob Hull that day.

After we processed in and sat down, Rob was looking through the program when he exclaimed, “Where the heck is God of Grace and God of Glory!!!” I looked, and sure enough it was not there. We started trying to remember when we had ever been to a commencement ceremony that did not include that hymn — and could not.

Later that day I kept thinking about that conversation. Being a retired librarian and the College Historian, I started digging back through the programs from former years. There it was – again and again and again. All the way back to 1948! Strange. Why did it start? Why did it stop? 

It was a few years before I thought about it again. This time I decided to research more about who had written the hymn, and to see if I could find a connection. At that time, I found that the hymn had been written in 1930 by Harry Emerson Fosdick, but didn’t see anything linking it to WVWC. He was writing at a time between two World Wars, during the Great Depression, and was certainly living in difficult times – much like we are today.

One night this week that hymn started haunting me. It played in my mind all night. So, in the morning I looked up the words once again to be sure I was remembering them correctly:

Verse 1

God of Grace and God of Glory on thy people pour thy power;

Crown thine ancient Church’s story; Bring its bud to glorious flower

Grant us wisdom, grant us courage for the facing of this hour

For the facing of this hour

Verse 2

Lo! The hosts of evil round us Scorn thy Christ, assail his ways!

From the fears that long have bound us, Free our hearts to faith and praise

Grant us wisdom, Grant us courage; For the living of these days

For the living of these days

Verse 3

Cure thy children’s warring madness, Bend our pride to Thy control

Shame our wanton, selfish gladness, Rich in things and poor in soul

Grant us wisdom, Grant us courage, Lest we miss thy Kingdom’s goal

Lest we miss thy Kingdom’s goal

Verse 4

Set our feet on lofty places; Gird our lives that they may be

Armored with all Christlike graces, Pledged to set all captives free

Grant us wisdom, Grant us courage, That we fail not Them or Thee

That we fail not them nor Thee

Verse 5

Save us from weak resignation to the evils we deplore

Let the gift of Thy salvation be our glory evermore

Grant us wisdom, Grant us courage serving Thee whom we adore

Serving Thee whom we adore.

On further investigation in the Pharos, I discovered that Dr. Lewis Chrisman (who taught English Literature at Wesleyan from 1919-1956) had spent 2 years going through and analyzing the content of over 6,000 sermons and had written a 280 page book entitled Message of the American Pulpit, published in 1930. It had been glowingly reviewed by a group of religious leaders in the country who had organized The Religious Book Club. Yes, one of them was Harry Emerson Fosdick, the writer of God of Grace and God of Glory. 

That same year, in 1930, Fosdick wrote God of Grace and God of Glory.

So, I knew that Fosdick and Chrisman were aware of each other, but why start using the hymn in the 1948 Commencement ceremony? While adding information to Dr. Chrisman’s entry on DreamersAndGiants, I came across this:

(1947) Dr. Chrisman Speaks to Students. Dr. Chrisman spoke at the morning assembly on March 6, 1947. His topic was “What Doest Thou Here at Wesleyan?”. He quoted from Harry Fosdick’s book On Being a Real Person   and mentioned Fosdick’s new book, On Being Fit to Live With – Sermons on Post-War Christianity. [Pharos 1947-03-11, p.3]

The book he quoted included the following chapters, and you can read the book by clicking on the title above. The same for the “upcoming” one on Being Fit to Live With. Sounds like some great information for former, current, and future students!

• • • • • Shouldering Responsibility for Ourselves
        • What Being a Real Person Means
        • The Principle of Self-Acceptance
        • Getting Oneself Off One’s Hands
        • Dealing with Fear and Anxiety
        • Handling our Mischievous Consciences
        • Using All There Is in Us
        • Mastering Depression
        • The Principle of Released Power
        • The Practical Use of Faith

Postscript: Rob Hull died unexpectedly at a young age just months after that day. I will always appreciate his good work and the love he had for his students and this college.

I am writing this on New Year’s Eve 2024. It is that great time of year when everyone pauses to take stock of their lives. What is going well? What has been left undone? What priorities will be important in the new year?

It is a very exciting thing that, when I went back to see what my former priorities were, they are still the same and interchangeable from personal, family, and post-retirement librarian perspectives.  Hooray!!!! 

Several years ago, on March 3, 2018, I wrote a blog entry about this very topic. It is called, Purposes – Or, What Are You Doing? Having been retired for 3 quarters of a year by then, it was a question I was often asked – and often asked of myself. It is all still true and relevant. Now 7 ½ years into retirement, I am making pretty great progress on those goals. In all of these areas, I am Collecting-Organizing-Preserving-and Sharing the stories of those who have come before. 

Here are some of those projects:

• Annotated Index: Seminary Herald (1893-1896)
• Annotated Index: Seminary Collegiate (1900-1904)
• *Working on the Annotated Index of the Pharos, especially from 1976-current. These papers have not been digitized, and there is 50 years worth of history in them! 
• Annotated Index of Alumni Publications Extremely incomplete at present.
• Alumni Adventures
• Faculty Adventures
• This Day in Wesleyan History: General (pulled from Pharos, Sundials, etc. as I come across them. There are plans for more specialized versions of this as well, such as This Day in Wesleyan Athletics, This Day in Wesleyan Theater, etc.)
• The Building section on DreamersAndGiants has been updated to include links to articles about their construction and other things……This is in preparation for an online course which is being developed. 
• Debate Topics in the Early 1900s (These are insane)
• Lists – lots and lots of lists.
• This year we have some student interns involved, and hoping to increase the student participation further. It is THEIR heritage as well!! And they are regularly making history themselves during their time here.

So here is to another year of finding treasures in college publications – and organizing them – and sharing them. Happy New Year, Bobcats!

The Spirit of WVWC is Alive and Well and Growing!

In the past couple of weeks I have seen it and heard it everywhere. I met with two classes full of freshmen to explain to them why we are having Founders Day and what that might entail. I gave a very brief history of the school, and shared that there would be speeches and awards, and that they would see representatives of the Orange Line (including me for the very first time in all these years – but that is probably another entire blog full of emotions).

Founders Day is also one of the very few times that they can experience the full community of WVWC (past, present, and future) all in one place. The truth is that most of them were planning to attend, but under varying levels of protest. This is not unusual –  in fact I have experienced this with decades of classes of my own, classmates of mine from long ago, and even some colleagues on the faculty! I explained that they would see new trustees installed (and what those are), and also they would see Alumni Awards bestowed. Click on the link below to read about these people. They are all beyond impressive and amazing. No really……do it. Especially if you were not in Buckhannon on Friday afternoon!

Founders Day 2024-10-11

Some of the experiences during this weekend included:

• Hundreds of Alumni greeting each other, remembering stories sharing news. Children of these alumni with eyes glowing and thinking about when they can come here to be part of it all – already feeling included, but beginning to dream their own dreams.
• Trustees meeting with current students to see what their dreams were and how they could find ways to help those dreams come true.
• Faculty reuniting with former students and being excited about the ways that those students had turned all of those dreams and classes and assignments into lives full of meaning and progress.
• President Moore inviting Wesleyan Society members at the breakfast on Saturday morning to close their eyes for 30 seconds and visualize the people who had made an impact on their lives here. That was not nearly long enough to cover them all, but when he asked for names to be shared, it was an impressive list of faculty and staff from over the decades. He explained that all of that was still happening here, but then shared names of those teaching and leading now. Names change, but the experience is the same.

To top off the weekend, the Chapel Service on Sunday morning was wonderful. You can see the full bulletin by clicking here: Founders Day Chapel Service 2024.

Speaker, Monty Brown (Class of 1974), completely blew me away with his sermon. With his wonderful storytelling style, he wove a tale of a little girl and her grandfather. Working from a passage in Ephesians, Chapter 3, it ranged from their bond through the years to the wonder of Disney’s Figment to the fact that grandpa had found something even more amazing than that. “Now to him who by the power at work within us is able to accomplish abundantly far more than all we can ask or imagine, to him be glory in the church and in Christ Jesus to all generations, forever and ever. Amen.”

The Founders would have been excited to see all that has come of their work in the 1800s. WVWC in 2024 is more than they could ever have asked or imagined.

Just when I thought that was the highlight of the weekend, Dean of the Chapel Jonathan Acord included a closing prayer adapted from the United Methodist Book of Worship. It was the perfect way to tie together all of these experiences throughout the weekend.

Homecoming Prayer

Eternal and loving God, today we give thanks to you for your goodness through all the years of worship and witness in this place.

For your grace in calling us to be your people, for your love revealed to us in Christ your Son, for your gift of the Spirit and the joy of salvation:

We give thanks, O God.

For those who established this College, for their faith and vision, for their gifts and abilities:

We give thanks, O God.

For those who have been members of this community, for those who have given freely of their time and money, for those whose wisdom guided our College:

We give thanks, O God.

For those who have taught and served here; for all who have confessed here that Jesus is Lord; for all who today help cultivate student leaders:

We give thanks, O God.

Give us the assurance that we too belong to that great cloud of witnesses, and that, by your power that is at work within us, we too may accomplish abundantly far more than all we can ask or imagine.

Amen.

Emeritus is a term generally used as an honorary title for a distinguished career. It is quite often used to honor retiring faculty members with ten or more years of service to the institution.

At student-centered WVWC, we also have an Emeritus Club. Alumni who have graduated more than 50 years ago are invited to join this group. It was organized and established on May 20, 1961 by alumni with a great love for the college and appreciation for the education received here.

The Club was the vision of one of Wesleyan’s greatest leaders and benefactors, Dr. Clyde O. Law 1909, Hon. 1952. It provides members a fellowship for remembering their time in college, a way to express their appreciation and support, a way to honor those who have been important in their lives, and a way to stay connected to each other and to the college. To get an idea of Clyde Law’s state of mind, here is an article he wrote in 1947, entitled Wesleyan, Of Thee I Dream.

Remember – Appreciate – Honor – Connection

These people arrived here as Dreamers, with many questions, plans, options and their whole lives before them.

Their lives after graduation have been full.

Many became Giants in their families, their churches, their professions, their communities, and more.

• Clergy
• Doctors
• Lawyers
• Educators — at all levels from early childhood to higher education. Some have become Professors at WVWC as well as many other colleges and universities
• College Administrators at many colleges and universities, and some have used their education and experience to strengthen and lead West Virginia Wesleyan College.

Many have served as Trustees of the college.

As a group, the members of the Emeritus Club have been generous in their support of building projects and other needs of the school. They have helped to upgrade classrooms, sound systems, and have been major contributors in academic, arts, and athletic areas of the college. They do these things because they want to make sure that the Wesleyan that helped to form their lives always stays relevant for the students of today.

The Emeritus Club Newsletter tells stories of their lives, helps keep them connected to each other and to WVWC. For many years, this newsletter has not been available to those outside of this group. During the summer of 2021, in honor of their 60th anniversary, I scanned and uploaded all of them (166 issues) to PagesInTime. (Many thanks to Brett Miller and Michael Winston for their help!) 

Editors who have made these newsletters possible include the following: 

Click Here to Browse or Search the Emeritus Club Newsletters from 1973-2021. 

You will find out things about the college that you may not have known! Sadly we do not have copies of the first newsletters in our archive. We begin with Volume 3, Number 4  (March 1977). If you have earlier issues, please contact historian@wvwc.edu.

The latest issue has not yet been uploaded to PagesInTime, but you can read it in full by Clicking Here.  This issue is a true celebration of all that the Emeritus Club has meant, and a history of the organization is included. Please take the time to read it! 

Emeritus Faculty

Emeritus Club (Alphabetical)

Emeritus Club (By Graduation Year)

Please Note:

Information for these lists has been gathered from Pharos, Sundials, and Emeritus Club Newsletters, by an ongoing process that I call Information Mining. Any further information or corrections you may have can be sent to historian@wvwc to be added to these lists.

We have all been there. That between time.

Not quite away from the familiar, and not quite sure of the new.

It happens at all stages of life, and it happens for everyone.

We are at the threshold of something.

I recently encountered this word on my Facebook feed. It was one I had heard before at the time of the death of my colleague, Professor Robert Hull. One of his former students recalled his talking about liminality and sharing an article with her. Here is her tribute to Rob and to the power of his teaching. When I recently saw the word again, I went back and reread this tribute. In an indirect way, he was still teaching from the grave. 

The word Liminality comes from the Latin word limins (threshold) and was the topic for Arnold van Gennep’s work (Rites of Passage) in which he explored transitions during such times. (I believe this is what he gave Krysta that day.)

Liminal Space is a place where great growth occurs and transformation takes place. It is a place where we can think about all we have experienced in the familiar and make decisions about what we want the future to hold.

The more I read, the more I realized that the whole world is experiencing Liminality right now. A couple of examples!

High School students are about to graduate, and are on the threshold between school days and college, work, marriage, or other paths. Maybe they have been accepted to college, but are not yet part of that world.

Likewise, college students are about to cross a threshold into work, graduate school, marriage, or other paths. They are still part of their college world, but are feeling that liminal awkwardness.

Covid seems to be over (oh, don’t we hope), but it is not really gone yet. We still need to be vigilant.

The world is helplessly watching as millions are displaced from their homes in Ukraine. People whose very lives are liminal. Just weeks ago, they were going about their daily lives in places that are no longer inhabitable. Families are torn apart, homes destroyed, an entire nation caught between the before and after.

WVWC is in a liminal space, with an Interim President, and Interim Dean, and is in search of a Director of Library Services and a Director of Alumni Affairs, just to name a few. It is a great time to be thinking about the time ahead.

The United Methodist Church is at a crossroads, and it is not entirely clear how that will all work out. They have been there before. What will 2022 bring?

Seasons

Just days ago the temperature was in the 70s, and now we’ve had a couple of days of snow. Definitely Liminal Space between Winter and Spring.

Stages of Life and Relationships

Engagement is a time of liminality. You are committed to one another, but not yet married. Many things need to be figured out about the wedding details as well as about priorities for your lives and family priorities.

Pregnancy is a time of liminality. You are very aware that there is a new life involved. Someone for whom you will be responsible and someone that will change your life forever. It is a threshold time not only for the expectant parents, but for the one literally being created in the womb – and who will be crossing over a threshold at birth. We constantly move between stages of life, with liminal space in between them.

Moving from job to job can be a confusing time. You may find that you are a lame duck at your old job, but not yet in a place where you can dive into the new one.

Moving from one house or city to another is definitely a Liminal time. Boxes are packed and things are in flux. If you are going to a new town, you will need to find your way around and learn where things are. Who will cut your hair? Which doctor or bank is best for you? Where did you put the toothpaste?!? So many questions. After a time, you will find all of these things familiar. The time in between is Liminal time.

Retirement is a time of liminality. You knew who you were and what you should be doing each day. Some are almost completely defined by the job that they do, and have a hard time determining who they will be after retirement. Others embrace the opportunity to spend their days in new ways.

Liminality is a time for creativity and growth. Professor Rob Hull said that without liminal space there is no transformation. As difficult as it may be at times, it is a time to be embraced.

Some readings:

• Rites of Passage, by Arnold von Gennep (1909) [available for borrowing on Internet Archive]
• A Liminality Primer, by Timothy Carson [website and resources which is an outgrowth of a doctoral dissertation]

March 10, 2022 was a sad day for West Virginia Wesleyan as legendary soccer coach, Gavin Donaldson lost his battle with cancer. Gavin was a respected colleague, mentor to hundreds, and a coach worthy of inclusion with WVWC greats from the past.

In fact, as I think of him today (March 11, 2022) I feel certain that he is surrounded by those long-serving greats and that they are all enjoying a conversation about athletics at WVWC. I would love to be able to listen in on this! Click on each one to learn more!

Harry Stansbury 1891-1966

Cebe Ross 1901-1953

David Reemsnyder 1908-1979

Hank Ellis 1921-2015

Soccer began at WVWC as a club team in 1959, and was given official status as a collegiate sport in 1962. Most coaches averaged 8 years of service. Gavin coached the team for 31 years.

He was elected to be inducted into the West Virginia Soccer Hall of Fame, which was to happen just days after his death. The announcement stated, “Over the course of 36 seasons as a head coach, Donaldson has accumulated 402 wins including 260 victories in his 31-year career at WVWC. In 1994, Donaldson led the Bobcats to an NAIA national title en route to NAIA and NSCAA National of the Year. The West Virginia Wesleyan men’s soccer coaching staff was named Division II National Staff of the Year by United Soccer Coaches for the 2020 season (played in the spring of 2021)”.

Always a strong advocate for academics as well as athletics, Gavin touched many lives. Alan Riches posted this image on Facebook, and it is a typical sentiment of many. If you have a memory of Gavin or a tribute to him, you can click here to submit it. You can also read things that others have written.

Happy Birthday to WVWC! 

When thinking about the history of West Virginia Wesleyan College, I often wonder about those first students. The ones who graduated from the West Virginia Conference Seminary (the first name of the school).

Who were they? What did they study? Since the school did not offer college level degrees until 1900, it may seem to us that those early students had an easy time of things. The 1890 catalog includes the courses of study for that time. They offered the Classical, Scientific, and Literary Courses of Study as well as Normal School preparation for teachers. The last of the Seminary Graduates were in 1908, as programs transitioned to fully college level over several years.

When looking over this curriculum, I would say that many of us would have a very hard time mastering all of this! The print above is very small, so here is a summary chart. The number after each is the number of terms the subject is required. One thing that stands out to me is that there are courses across all programs that resemble our General Studies curriculum of today.

I found a listing of all Seminary Graduates in the 1947 Alumni Directory, and created a chart of the various information available. In summary:

• Over 500 students graduated from the West Virginia Conference Seminary
• by 1947, they lived in 28 different states (WV being the highest at 213)
• Vocations were widely varied, with the top being Business, Attorney, Clergy, Teachers, and Physicians. Also included were 14 Higher Education Professors and Administrators, Judges, Government Officials, Civil Engineers, Bankers, and a Missionary. These folks left Buckhannon ready for just about anything! (That has not changed)
• Female students were right in the middle of it all, and the school was specifically founded with the goal of offering opportunities to them as well as to the male students.

To see the full list, Grouped by Graduation Year and Sorted by Degrees Earned, Click Here.

Several of these people were very familiar to me. I have written previously about some of them:

Roy Reger: First in Line

Opening Day: September 3, 1890

Roy McCuskey’s First Hand Account of the Fire

Orange and Black Are the Colors of Leadership (Frank Thompson)

Bravo to all of the Seminary Graduates! And to those who have followed their footsteps for 131 years.

The Heavenly Host gained a wonderful soprano voice this week.

That voice belongs to Caroline Dees, who has also been widely known to light up a room with her distinctive laugh. Caroline spent her entire teaching career at WVWC, mentoring and inspiring generations of students from 1969-2006. For 37 years, she shared her wit, humor, and joy of music.  And always with a smile.

She also had a love of libraries which started way back in her high school days in  in Atlanta, where she was a member of the North Fulton High School Main Library Staff. This love continued throughout her life as she received her MLIS from the University of South Carolina through a distance education program in 1995. She put those skills to good use in the Music Library in Loar Hall.

There are too many stories to even know where to begin. Stories of voice lessons, traveling to far-off places to share music together, and of Caroline singing at the weddings of her students and friends.

For the purpose of this writing, I would like to focus on one event that stands out in the minds of many. Caroline’s role as Satan in The Descent into Hell, which the college commissioned for the celebration of its 90th birthday. It took place in Wesley Chapel on Thursday, October 16, 1980 at 8:30 pm.

The full program for the evening is available here.

This list of musicians represents a multitude of Wesleyan’s finest students and choir alumni who had gathered for this special occasion. I am sure that rehearsals were an amazing amount of fun.

I am sure each of them could tell stories of how Caroline Dees was part of their journey, and I hope that many will click on this link and share them.  As they are shared, you can click here and watch the story of the impact of Caroline’s life.

Larry Parsons shared this message on Facebook, and is a beautiful blessing and benediction. It speaks so much about their work together through the years.

In paradisum deducant te angeli: May the angels lead you into paradise.

The Thoughts and Memories collection was started in Spring 2021 in order to give faculty, staff, alumni, and friends of the college a place to share their stories  of people, buildings, events, groups (or other!) from their time at WVWC. Although many do so on Facebook and other platforms, those are not saved in this more permanent way. Here is a link to the full collection.

You can submit your thoughts and memories about Caroline (and about other people as well) by clicking here. And, you can even add photos if you like!

Update: November 8, 2021

A beautiful Service of Celebration was held in Wesley Chapel on November 6, 2021. As part of that service, a Reader’s Theater Monologue was presented by Jane Weimer Godwin (1976), Sarah Carr Parsons (1982), Don Gardner (1977), and Dave Carson (1974).

Continue reading Remembering Caroline Dees